Skip to main content

The circle is complete.

Sometimes you can view a case that appears to be overwhelming.What other explanation can there be for the situation other than the guilt of the accused. The danger with the present system we run is that people cannot afford to represent themselves properly in Court. The investigation and prosecution system in New Zealand and the Prison system for that matter has become corporatized to such a high degree that the individual in society is simply overwhelmed and defenceless  in the face of the complete resources at the disposal of the Crown. These resources are not just the investigation and prosecution resources but also control of the media. In the opposite camp the resources devoted to funding the defence of people are meagre and deliberately so. The last thing the government wants is for one of its corporate departments to wreck the work carried out by another of its departments. So unless you are rich you are at the mercy of the Court system. A system that is so cynical in its view of the individual that people are presumed to be guilty by all those people within  the system. After all their salary is being paid. This corporatization is reaching its zenith with private prisons and the creation of a Public Defenders Office. All functions are now within the realm of one corporate entity. This is a very worrying development from a constitutional point of view as all sectors of the Court system are now controlled by the executive. There is now no longer any separation of powers in the Court room itself. When Defence Counsel themselves are employed and controlled by the executive branch of government i.e. they are state servants the circle is complete. You can readily understand the prosecution being employed  by the executive afterall they are representing the government. But when the defence bar is employed by the executive who are they representing. Are they representing the defendant or are they representing the executive. When the chips are down and the hard unpopular decisions have to be made who does a state servant owe allegiance to. The state of course how could it be any other way. Its interesting to note that practically all the senior lawyers in the PDS are drawn from a state background. I know you dont have time to be worried about all this. You have your everyday life to lead. So thats why I thought you might be interested in a post that presents the argument. I would be interested to hear your views. Have a great day.


  1. Maua Faleauto6:59 PM

    The same attitude is revealed in the Law Reports as only those cases which support the State line make it into the reports-inconvenient common law lies on the files of lawyers who achieved inconvenient results.

    Inconvenient argument in the law courts is often completely ignored and no written record is made.

    This hegemony corrodes the very fabric of our society.

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review Flight of the Fantail.

Book review Flight of the Fantail Steph Matuku Huia Publishers
I asked for it in the local bookshop. It was in the children’s section at the rear of the shop. The assistant found it for me. When I paid for it, the teller asked; do you want it gift wrapped? Clearly thinking I was buying it as a gift for my teenage child. When I said no and paid for it, he said enjoy. I didn’t say anything. I could have done a long ramble and said well, it’s written by a novelist in Taranaki who I follow on Twitter. And I am interested in writing so I want to see how you write a novel. But I didn’t. I was just happy to have bought it. So, I took the book home and looked at it carefully, read the back cover, looked at the copyright page, the dedication. The book was over 350 pages. I thought, wow, this is serious stuff. This is pro level. The whole book, it’s weight, it’s feel, it’s look shouted quality. I could tell there was love in the book. I read the first chapter. The writing was clear like the wa…

How do Defence Lawyers sleep at night.

How do defence lawyers sleep at night?
I must admit when I saw the photos I was totally creeped out. It took me a while to get over them.  I had a flashback of defending a person charged with having sex with a woman who had an IQ of around 70. I agonized about the case and taking it to trial. But it was resolved on the court steps with a guilty plea and no prison sentence. A week of hot showers finally washed the case off me. I don’t think I did many more cases after that involving sexual crimes. Not because I wouldn’t or couldn’t. But perhaps word got around that I didn’t like women being raped and those defendants didn’t gravitate towards me. I felt more at home defending people charged with stealing vast amounts of money, sometimes off old people in Rest Homes. Was there something about the fact that no blood was spilled which enabled me to shut off the devastation inflicted on these victims? Did I have a fatal flaw? Should I get psychotherapy? Should I change to family law, where I…

New Year's Eve

New Year’s Eve 

Downtown central Auckland, New Zealand I hadn’t been out for a while. There were four of us. Bill was the president of a motorcycle gang. His friend Rangi was a big Maori guy. They had been in prison together. Kelly was Bill’s girlfriend, over the last week. She was very young and thin, with a face like an avatar. We were an unusual group. I was a bankrupt lawyer. We loaded up on pure Peruvian coke and Long Island Iced Teas and headed downtown. Rangi was so drunk he was sick in the back of the car. With a compassion born of doing a lag together, Bill cleaned him up and we found him a new shirt. Downtown was pumping. We headed for a small club in an old art deco building next to the waterfront. The security at the door let us in and we paid money to a bored looking girl at a desk who ushered us down the stairs. The club was packed and the carpet was wet with booze. As we stood in the queue at the bar, I noticed a tall blonde girl a few people over. I was pretty high. Thi…